Louisiana Birth Certificate Set for En Banc Hearing

Several times over the last few years I have written about a case that started in Louisiana.   You can read back from that post to get the details, but I’ll repeat them in brief.  

A gay male couple, Oren Adar and Mickey Smith, adopted a boy who was born in Louisiana.   (The joint adoption was completed in New York.)   Adar and Smith wanted (and needed) a birth certificate with their names on it.    Louisiana  would not issue the birth certificate.     

It’s not that Louisiana doesn’t issue new birth certificates on completion of adoptions–it does.   But Louisiana would not have permitted this adoption–it’s one of the states that only allows married couples and single individuals to adopt.  (This restriction conveniently bars all lesbian and gay couples from adopting, since they cannot be married in Louisiana.)   And so Louisiana does not want to give this particular couple a new birth certificate.  

Adar and Smith won their case in the district court and they won their case before a panel of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit.   Now the Fifth Circuit has agreed to hear the case en banc.    It’s hard for me to see much good in this.  

I know that a number of people who visit the blog find it troubling that states issue new birth certificates after adoption.   There’s been a lot of discussion about that.   I’d ask that you just set those concerns aside for the moment.  

Instead, think about this case as one focusing on differential treatment.   If a state issues new birth certificates upon completion of adoption can they do so for some adoptions but not all adoptions?   In particular, can they do so for adoptions from within Louisiana and not for adoptions in other states?   

I think it is fairly clear that the Full Faith and Credit Clause of the United States Constitution answers this question.   Louisiana is obliged to treat a New York adoption just as it would a Louisiana adoption.  If it issues a new birth certificate after a Louisiana adoption, it must do the same after a New York adoption.   It cannot pick and choose among New York adoptions and it cannot reject all New York adoptions.  

That said, I do wonder why the en banc hearing was granted.  If you read the panel opinion (which was 3-0) you’ll see a couple of other issues that were raised by the state.  These are more technical and are beyond the scope of the blog, but I’m frankly surprised that the state garnered the votes for the en banc rehearing.   It’s a case worth watching.   Argument is the week of January 17.

Advertisements

One response to “Louisiana Birth Certificate Set for En Banc Hearing

  1. Julie this is off topic but I don’t believe you have addressed this particular issue on your blog before and thought it might be interesting to have you and your readers weigh in on this case and others like it. http://news.yahoo.com/s/ac/20101112/us_ac/7170984_illegal_children_legislating_immigration_reform_on_the_backs_of_children_1
    A co-worker has asked for my help in locating his baby brother who disappeared in Los Angeles in late 1978 shortly after he and his family illegally immigrated from Mexico. He was 2 at the time of his disappearance. He is feared dead or adopted and I am beginning to research what happens when illegal immigrants are separated from their children. My friend’s mother and father were never able to find him while he was a minor = this article addresses what happens when children spend years in an adoptive or foster home against the wishes of their parents who are now complete strangers to the adopted/foster child.
    As an aside my co-worker was raised in east los angeles with 7 siblings in substandard conditions, graduated top of his class and is a senior associate architect at one of the largest commercial architecture firms in the country. He owns lots of property and drives a porche – the american dream is alive and well.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s